Sex Work and Prostitution in North America: Canada’s Courts and the US Patchwork

Last Updated: November 2026

Overview

Canada and the United States share a border and very different sex work laws. Canada criminalizes buying sex but not selling it, a version of the Nordic model that the Supreme Court of Canada partly upheld in July 2025, with a broader challenge still before Ontario’s top court. The United States criminalizes prostitution in every state, with one exception: licensed brothels in a handful of rural Nevada counties. Change there happens state by state, and bills to decriminalize and bills to punish buyers more harshly are being introduced in the same legislatures.

This branch of the global sex work hub covers Canada and the United States; Mexico is covered on the Latin America branch. It describes the laws and arguments without taking a side and is maintained as they change.

How the Competing Frames Play Out in North America

Criminal law and public order. In the United States this is the default frame. Prostitution is policed mainly by cities and states as a misdemeanour, often through street sweeps and online stings, and federal law reaches online advertising and trafficking. Religious conservatives, such as Canada’s Evangelical Fellowship and the Association for Reformed Political Action, which intervened to defend Canada’s law, combine moral and public order arguments.

Abolition, or the “equality model.” Survivor-led organizations and groups such as World Without Exploitation argue that buyers and third parties should be prosecuted and people selling sex treated as victims and offered exit services. Canada’s 2014 law was built on this reasoning, and Maine adopted a version in 2023.

Labor rights and decriminalization. Coalitions including Decrim NY, Decriminalize Sex Work and the Woodhull Freedom Foundation in the US, and the Canadian Alliance for Sex Work Law Reform, argue that criminalizing buyers still exposes sex workers to danger. Civil liberties groups such as the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and the feminist legal group LEAF have backed their court challenges.

Online speech and technology. A frame particular to the US concerns the internet. Since the 2018 federal law known as FOSTA-SESTA made websites liable for content that facilitates prostitution, sex worker groups and digital rights organizations argue it pushed work offline and made screening clients harder. The law’s supporters say it was needed to stop platforms profiting from trafficking.

The Legal Spectrum in North America

Buyer criminalization applies across Canada under the Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act (PCEPA) of 2014, and in Maine for selling, which the state largely decriminalized in 2023 while keeping penalties for buyers.

Full criminalization applies in the other 49 US states and the District of Columbia, where selling, buying and organizing are crimes, though penalties and enforcement vary widely.

Legalization exists only in Nevada, where counties under 700,000 people may license brothels. Only 10 counties allow prostitution, and only inside licensed brothels; it remains illegal in Las Vegas and Reno.

Decriminalization has not been adopted in any US state or Canadian province, which in Canada would require federal action because criminal law is national.

Country by Country

Canada. In the 2013 Bedford decision, the Supreme Court of Canada struck down bans on brothels, living on the earnings of prostitution and public communication, finding they endangered sex workers. Parliament responded in 2014 with PCEPA, which made buying sex a crime for the first time, along with receiving a material benefit from someone else’s sex work, procuring and advertising others’ services. In September 2023 the Ontario Superior Court dismissed a broad Charter challenge by the Canadian Alliance for Sex Work Law Reform, noting that decriminalization might be better policy but that the choice belonged to Parliament.

On 24 July 2025, in R v Kloubakov, the Supreme Court unanimously upheld the material benefit and procuring offences, ruling that, read correctly, they still allow sex workers to hire security and take the safety measures Bedford protected. The court left the right to life and liberty arguments for the Alliance’s appeal, which remains pending at the Court of Appeal for Ontario. In October 2026 the Supreme Court also ruled that defendants in some sex trade cases can cross-examine complainants about the commercial side of their past sex work.

United States. Prostitution is a state crime, so the legal picture is a patchwork. Maine’s 2023 law, signed by Governor Janet Mills after she vetoed an earlier version, is the first partial decriminalization on the equality model in any state. It also raised child prostitution offences from misdemeanours to felonies.

New York has two competing bills: Cecilia’s Act, which would decriminalize consensual sex work, and the Sex Trade Survivors Justice and Equality Act, which would follow the Nordic approach. Neither has passed. In Washington state, a 2026 bill to make buying sex a felony was defeated, and Colorado advocates plan to reintroduce a decriminalization bill. Some cities have acted on narrower measures; New Orleans voted in 2025 to give sex workers conditional immunity when they report crimes.

Nevada. Licensed brothels have operated since 1971, with workers classed as independent contractors and subject to regular health testing. In December 2025, workers at Sheri’s Ranch in Pahrump began an effort to unionize, a first for the legal industry. Religious and anti-trafficking groups have pursued county votes to ban brothels; Lyon County voters rejected a ban in 2018, and the county is drafting a new ballot question.

Federal level. FOSTA-SESTA remains in force. The SAFE SEX Workers Study Act, reintroduced in December 2024 by Senators Elizabeth Warren and Ron Wyden and Representative Ro Khanna, would order the first federal study of the law’s effects on sex workers and trafficking cases. It has not advanced in a Republican-controlled Congress.

Recent Changes

Canada’s law has moved mainly through courts and Parliament’s responses to them: Bedford in 2013, PCEPA in 2014, and a decade of challenges since. Each round has narrowed the question. The Supreme Court has now accepted that Parliament can regulate the sex trade and pursue reducing demand as a goal; what remains open is whether specific provisions, including the purchase ban itself, violate sex workers’ Charter rights.

In the United States, the 2010s brought both a federal crackdown on online advertising, culminating in FOSTA-SESTA and the seizure of Backpage in 2018, and the first state-level decriminalization bills, introduced in New York, Massachusetts, Maine and Washington, D.C. from 2019 onward. Maine’s 2023 law marked the first time a state chose either reform path, and it chose the equality model.

Active Debates

Canada’s Ontario appeal. As of November 2026, the Court of Appeal for Ontario has not ruled on the Alliance’s challenge to PCEPA, including the purchase ban. Whatever it decides could be appealed to the Supreme Court.

US state legislatures. Decriminalization and equality model bills are both being introduced, and in New York they sit side by side in the same legislature. Maine’s law will be the first US test of the equality model, and data from its first years is likely to be cited by both sides.

Nevada’s brothels. The Pahrump unionization effort and renewed county ballot campaigns are testing the only legal market in the country from two directions at once.

This is a maintained reference page, last updated November 2026. It is revised as laws and circumstances change, and major changes are covered as dated posts in the News section and linked from here.

Related Links

Discussion Questions

  1. How does your country’s approach compare with Canada’s or the United States’?
  2. Canada’s law punishes buyers but not sellers. Is that a fair way to divide responsibility?
  3. Should judges or elected lawmakers decide whether sex work laws are safe for workers?
  4. Why do you think only Nevada allows legal brothels in the United States?
  5. Can a law aimed at websites change what happens on the street?
  6. Imagine you are a state legislator in New York with both bills on your desk. What questions would you ask?
  7. Should brothel workers be allowed to form a union like workers in other industries?
  8. Is it a problem when each state or province has its own rules on an issue like this?
  9. Why might supporters of different models read the same evidence from Sweden and New Zealand so differently?
  10. Would a cross-border difference in laws, like the one between Canada and the US, affect how people behave?