Healthcare Systems in North America: Rising US Uninsurance and Canada’s Two-Tier Test

Last Updated: November 2026

Overview

The two countries of North America are moving in different directions on the same question: who pays for care. In the United States, the share of working-age adults without insurance has risen since enhanced federal subsidies expired at the end of 2025, and new Medicaid work requirements take effect nationally in 2027. In Canada, where provincial single-payer plans cover everyone, Alberta has opened the country’s first legal two-tier system for some surgeries, setting up a test of the Canada Health Act.

This branch of the global healthcare hub covers the United States and Canada; Mexico is covered on the Latin America branch. It reports what systems do and what the evidence shows without advocating a model, and it is updated as circumstances change.

How the Competing Frames Play Out in North America

Health as a right. In Canada this frame is close to national identity, written into the Canada Health Act’s principles of universality and accessibility. In the United States, Democrats and advocacy groups use it to argue for expanding Medicaid, preserving marketplace subsidies or moving to single payer.

Market efficiency and choice. This frame is stronger in the United States than in any other wealthy country. Republicans argued during the 2025 subsidy debate that enhanced tax credits were wasteful spending that benefited insurers. In Canada, the Alberta government and the Fraser Institute argue that allowing private payment would shorten waits.

Solidarity and risk-pooling. Medicare for older Americans and Canada’s provincial plans pool risk across large populations. The US debate over Medicaid work requirements is partly a dispute over who should be inside the pool; supporters say requirements strengthen the program for the long term, while opponents say they remove eligible people through paperwork.

Fiscal sustainability. US health spending is the highest in the world, and Canadian health spending reached 12.7% of GDP in 2025, according to the Fraser Institute. Both countries’ debates turn on cost, from federal Medicaid savings in the US to provincial budgets and federal transfers in Canada.

The Financing Spectrum in North America

Single-payer provincial insurance covers Canada. Each province runs a public plan paying mostly private doctors and non-profit hospitals, under federal conditions tied to the Canada Health Transfer. Prescription drugs, dental care and vision are covered unevenly outside hospitals.

A mixed public-private system describes the United States: employer-sponsored private insurance for most working-age people, Medicare for those over 65, Medicaid for low-income people, subsidized marketplace plans under the Affordable Care Act, and tens of millions without coverage.

The law-versus-practice gap runs in both countries. Canadians are covered but can wait months for specialist treatment; many insured Americans face deductibles high enough that they skip care.

Country by Country

United States: coverage. The uninsured rate among adults aged 19 to 64 rose from 8.9% in 2024 to 11.2% in 2026, according to the Commonwealth Fund.

The enhanced ACA premium tax credits first passed in 2021 expired at the end of 2025 when Congress did not extend them, and marketplace enrollment dropped 13% as average premium payments rose 114%, according to KFF.

United States: Medicaid. The 2025 tax and spending law requires most Medicaid expansion enrollees to log 80 hours a month of work, study or volunteering and to renew eligibility every six months, starting in 2027. Nebraska became the first state to impose the requirement, with coverage losses beginning in August 2026.

The changes are projected to produce net enrollment losses of 11.5 million in Medicaid and 7.5 million in marketplace plans. The Commonwealth Fund projects the uninsured population will reach about 37 million by 2036, roughly its level when the ACA marketplaces opened.

Canada: waits and drugs. The median wait from GP referral to treatment was 28.6 weeks in 2025, according to the Fraser Institute’s annual physician survey, the second-longest in the survey’s history.

The 2024 Pharmacare Act set a first phase covering contraceptives and diabetes drugs, but only four provinces and territories signed agreements. The Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives says the federal Spring 2026 Economic Update effectively halts the rollout by signalling no new funding.

Canada: Alberta’s Bill 11. Passed in December 2025, the law lets doctors work in both the public system and private practice and charge patients directly for some publicly insured surgeries, with the first private surgeries starting in fall 2026. The Canadian Medical Association has warned it could worsen public wait times, and health coalitions and doctors’ groups say it creates a two-tier system that violates the Canada Health Act, which could expose Alberta to cuts in federal transfers. Premier Danielle Smith’s government says dual practice does not breach the Act and points to Quebec, where doctors must choose one system.

Recent Changes

Canada’s medicare took shape in the 1960s, beginning with Saskatchewan, and was codified in the 1984 Canada Health Act, which bans extra-billing and user fees for insured services. The 2005 Chaoulli ruling allowed private insurance for insured services in Quebec, and provinces have since expanded contracting with private clinics.

The ACA cut the US uninsured rate roughly in half after 2010, through Medicaid expansion and marketplace subsidies, and the enhanced credits of 2021 pushed marketplace enrollment to records. The reversal since 2025 is the largest coverage contraction since the ACA marketplaces opened.

Active Debates

US coverage before and after 2027. As of November 2026, states are preparing to implement work requirements by 1 January 2027. Whether Congress revisits the subsidies, and how many people lose Medicaid, will shape the next stage of the US debate.

The Canada Health Act test. Ottawa has said it will protect the Act but had not imposed penalties on Alberta as of late 2026. Other provinces, including Saskatchewan and Ontario, are watching how far Alberta’s model is allowed to go.

Pharmacare’s future. The law remains, but the existing agreements run only to 2029. Whether coverage expands to other provinces or new drug classes depends on federal funding decisions.

This is a maintained reference page, last updated November 2026. It is revised as laws and circumstances change, and major changes are covered as dated posts in the News section and linked from here.

Related Links

Discussion Questions

  1. How does your country’s health system compare with Canada’s or the United States’?
  2. Why might someone with health insurance still avoid seeing a doctor?
  3. Should people have to work or volunteer to receive public health coverage?
  4. Is it fair for patients who can pay to get surgery faster?
  5. Why do you think the United States has never adopted universal coverage?
  6. Imagine you are a doctor in Alberta. Would you work in both the public and private systems? Why?
  7. Should prescription drugs be covered the same way as hospital care?
  8. Which matters more in a health system: short waits or equal access?
  9. How should a federal government respond if a province or state breaks national health rules?
  10. What could the United States and Canada each learn from the other?